Wall of Champions
— Academic Bowl
| Year | Head Coach | ||
| 2005 | Mark Denton & Michelle Shearer | ||
| 2010 | Patrick Rosenburg & Edna Johnston | ||
| 2011 | Patrick Rosenburg & Edna Johnston | ||
| 2012 | Patrick Rosenburg & Edna Johnston | ||
| 2013 | Octavian Robinson & Eren Boden |
— Boys Cross Country
| Year | Head Coach | ||
| 1986 | Jay Cherry |
— Girls Cross Country
| Year | Head Coach | ||
| 1986 | Nancy Benton | ||
| 1988 | Nancy Benton | ||
| 1989 | Nancy Benton | ||
| 1990 | Nancy Benton | ||
| 1991 | Nancy Benton | ||
| 1992 | Nancy Benton |
— Football
| Year | Head Coach | ||
| 2001 | Andy Bonheyo | ||
| 2003 | Andy Bonheyo | ||
| 2004 | Andy Bonheyo | ||
| 2005 | Andy Bonheyo | ||
| 2006 | Andy Bonheyo | ||
| 2007 | Andy Bonheyo | ||
| 2008 | Andy Bonheyo | ||
| 2009 | Andy Bonheyo | ||
| 2010 | Andy Bonheyo | ||
| 2011 | Andy Bonheyo | ||
| 2014 | Joshua Doudt | ||
| 2015 | Ryan Bonheyo | ||
| 2016 | Ryan Bonheyo | ||
| 2017 | Ryan Bonheyo | ||
| 2018 | Ryan Bonheyo |
— Volleyball
| Year | Head Coach | ||
| 2001 | Vicki Kitsembel | ||
| 2003 | Vicki Kitsembel | ||
| 2004 | Vicki Kitsembel | ||
| 2006 | Vicki Kitsembel | ||
| 2007 | Vicki Kitsembel | ||
| 2008 | Vicki Kitsembel | ||
| 2009 | Vicki Kitsembel | ||
| 2010 | Vicki Kitsembel | ||
| 2013 | Vicki Kitsembel | ||
| 2014 | Vicki Kitsembel | ||
| 2015 | Vicki Kitsembel | ||
| 2018 | Christine DiMarco | ||
| 2021 | Christine DiMarco |
— Boys Basketball
| Year | Head Coach | ||
| 1993 | Jerry Bush | ||
| 1994 | Jerry Bush | ||
| 2007 | Vance Rewolinski | ||
| 2010 | James DeStefano | ||
| 2011 | James DeStefano | ||
| 2015 | James DeStefano | ||
| 2016 | James DeStefano | ||
| 2018 | James DeStefano | ||
| 2019 | James DeStefano | ||
| 2020 | James DeStefano | ||
| 2024 | James Steingieser |
— Girls Basketball
| Year | Head Coach | ||
| 2001 | Lorraine Stoltz | ||
| 2002 | Lorraine Stoltz | ||
| 2003 | Danny Biskupiak | ||
| 2004 | Danny Biskupiak | ||
| 2008 | Terry Berrigan | ||
| 2010 | Amy Mowl | ||
| 2014 | Amy Mowl | ||
| 2015 | Amy Mowl | ||
| 2016 | Amy Mowl | ||
| 2017 | Amy Mowl |
— Wrestling
| Year | Head Coach | ||
| 1987 | James Schartner | ||
| 1988 | James Schartner | ||
| 1995 | Jeffrey White | ||
| 1996 | Jeffrey White | ||
| 1997 | Jeffrey White | ||
| 1998 | Jeffrey White | ||
| 1999 | Jeffrey White | ||
| 2000 | Jeffrey White | ||
| 2002 | Jeffrey White | ||
| 2005 | Jeffrey White | ||
| 2010 | Christopher von Garrel | ||
| 2011 | Christopher von Garrel |
— Baseball
| Year | Head Coach | ||
| 2005 | Scott Morrison | ||
| 2016 | Chester Kuschmider | ||
| 2017 | Chester Kuschmider | ||
| 2018 | Chester Kuschmider | ||
| 2019 | Chester Kuschmider |
— Soccer
| Year | Head Coach | ||
| 1937 | James A. McVernon |
— Softball
| Year | Head Coach | ||
| 2008 | Mathis Hediger | ||
| 2010 | Mathis Hediger | ||
| 2011 | Mathis Hediger | ||
| 2015 | Mathis Hediger | ||
| 2019 | Jill Bianco |
— Boys Track & Field
| Year | Head Coach | ||
| 1986 | Dick Jones | ||
| 1987 | Dick Jones | ||
| 2017 | Randy Shank | ||
| 2019 | Randy Shank | ||
| 2023 | Randy Shank |
— Girls Track & Field
| Year | Head Coach | ||
| 1985 | Nancy Benton | ||
| 1988 | Nancy Benton | ||
| 2002 | Nancy Benton | ||
| 2003 | Dan Frank | ||
| 2015 | Randy Shank & Andy Bonheyo | ||
| 2016 | Randy Shank | ||
| 2017 | Randy Shank | ||
| 2019 | Randy Shank | ||
| 2022 | Randy Shank |